When we are told “You’re too close to it” we counter with “You’re too far away from it!”

Beth Bell, written in Spring 2025

In May 2024, Tiziana, Lee and Beth were awarded a wee bit of funding under Farming the Future’s field building strand to explore together what the agroecological movement needs to really shift systems in NI. We thought we might convene a network or a collective to “build capacity to test and trial new ways of working and being, to care for each other and the land, so that we can all keep going”. We talked about this work being about dreams and possibility, as well as capacity and convening. About knowing that we’re not alone, and also that we have the skills and resources we need to make change.

We said “There is an emergent food network in Northern Ireland that is working in complex conditions to regenerate and democratise the food system here. There is a loose collective of landworkers, activists, communities and citizens sharing knowledge and resources on an ad-hoc basis, coming together here and there to energise, empathise and support each other. But finding the time and headspace to work together to develop relationships is a constant challenge. This is a familiar picture right across movements in the UK but it is deeply exacerbated in NI by the legacy of the conflict and the political context in which Stormont is just back sitting after a two year absence. Yet, there is a moment happening, we all feel it. It just needs a bit of attention and resource to nourish it.”

We hosted events, were part of many others and took part in 100s of conversations in this time. We could see and feel that there were many glimmers of change across the food system (encompassing economy, farming, horticulture etc). At the same time we have each reflected on the sheer volume and intensity of research, reports, articles, blogs that are being published and shared every day. All with something to say. Many with something useful to say. Our reflection is to ask: When will there be the right bit of research? The one that is the magic bullet that cuts through, that convinces everyone, that changes the system? And unfortunately our answer is: there isn’t one. 

We believe that communities are fundamentally integral to genuine, just food system transformation and without some deep investigation on what is important and really matters to local communities, any new farming or horticultural initiative will be destined to become another ‘provider’ looking for ‘consumers’. We envisage something different for the transformation that is required to survive the challenges ahead. Small growers need community support and strong relationships among all the actors around food and exploring the depth of those relationships is very important at this moment in time in NI and will keep the focus on systemic change affecting society and the policy makers.   

Work that informs funders within NI of the deep need to resource systemic interventions in community in ways that, for the most part, they have failed to do. 

The work that is needed is systems change work – where the actions, themes, leverage points start to emerge and bubble up – and these will not be about a single issue/single system/single community etc. In NI there is work happening to change the food system, and the farming system, and the economy, but no real oversight of how it all connects – and little of it is being done with communities. Where it is done with communities, like via Carrick Greengrocers, we are seeing the system change in real time. Through conversations and reciprocity.  

Of particular interest to us is genuine community involvement in food system change – acknowledging the need to bring the community with you. It’s an investment in relationship building. To do this needs connection across community and food & farming.

Reciprocity

We used £1000 of this funding to support two events that each in their way contributed to the emerging agroecological system in NI. 

  • The Future is Already Here in November 2024 – Transition Together, Positive Carrickfergus and Cooperative Alternatives
  • The Big Small Growers Get Together in May 2025 – LWA NI, GrowIN, Nourish NI, Cooperative Alternatives, Climate Co Centre, FFCC, NFFN

We did this as we know that we need lots of different parts of the system to be resourced. None of us can achieve anything on our own. By sharing this funding, we both wanted to support other important gatherings, but also to signal that reciprocity and generosity are an important feature of the new world we are all trying to build.